Ulster’s 30-6 Guinness Pro12 victory against Leinster on Saturday wasn’t without its controversy.
18 minutes into the clash, Leinster conceded a penalty try and Rob Kearney was sent to the sin bin for his foul on Ruan Pienaar.
Ulster were on the attack when Pienaar chipped a kick deep into the Blues’ 22 and chased after it in pursuit of a try. Kearney appeared to make no effort to get out of the scrum-half’s way and proceeded to take him out off the ball, causing the South African to go crashing down to the ground in a heap.
Referee George Clancy went to the TMO, then showed Kearney the yellow card and awarded a contentious penalty try to the Northern province.
While everyone was unanimous in agreement that Kearney deserved a yellow card for the foul, very few could understand why the referee decided to award Ulster the penalty try when Kearney wasn’t the last man, and also it looked as if Pienaar was never going to win the footrace to touch down a try.
https://twitter.com/eimoflynn/status/726421173928517633
George Clancys a joke, terrible decision a yellow yes but never a penalty try #ULSvLEIN
— Deano (@Dean__Sheridan) April 30, 2016
Not sure about the penalty try decision. Would have to be a try without any reasonable doubt. McGrath was running for it also. #ULSvLEIN
— Stephen Hovenden Keane (@SHovendenKeane) April 30, 2016
George Clancy is determined to have max impact on game. Ref cam showed definite yellow but never a penalty try #ULSvLEIN #Pro12 #pro12rugby
— Ronan Quinn (@RonanJQuinn) April 30, 2016
Shocking by George Clancy, penalty yes penalty try no. #ULSvLEIN
— MARK GASKIN (@MARK_GASKIN) April 30, 2016
@PRO12rugby poor standard of refereeing on show again with George Clancy showing his typical low standard #ULSvLEIN
— Blindside (@Pro14tipster) April 30, 2016
Is George the worst referee in Rugby or just in the top three???#ULSvLEIN #pro12
— Declan (@decbreen) April 30, 2016
Yellow yes, penalty try no. Still, it's given ULS 10 – 0 LEIN #PRO12Rugby #ULSvLEIN
— Proper Rugby Kino (@RugbyKino) April 30, 2016
Harsh call the yellow card would have been enough!! #ULSvLEIN
— Wendy Gallagher✨ (@WendyGallagher_) April 30, 2016
George Clancy clearly showing his allegiances. Definite yellow, but no way a penalty try. #ULSvLEIN
— Lugh. (@Dentistry777) April 30, 2016
Shocking decision. No problem with the yellow but never a penalty try. Clancy a joke #ULSvLEIN
— Rory O’Mór (Curate's Egg) (@curates_egg) April 30, 2016
#ULSvLEIN Penalty yes. Yellow harsh. Penalty try…absurd. Pennar very South American reaction @UlsterRugby @leinsterrugby @PRO12rugby
— Conor Dempsey 🕊️🇺🇦🇮🇪🕊 (@Conor_Dempsey) April 30, 2016
https://twitter.com/N_Mulv15/status/726416889757466624