
Rugby
Share
Published 10:49 13 May 2018 BST
Explore more on these topics:
While we would have gone for the indefatigable Leinster forward Scott Fardy from the shortlist of five nominees decided upon before the final - Maxime Machenaud, Johnny Sexton and Tadhg Furlong were the others - Nakarawa was a class above for Racing on their journey to Bilbao.
Our major complaint with the awarding of the trophy was just how rapidly it all went down.
The public had a say, along with an expert rugby panel of six members, in coming up with that shortlist but to decide on the best player over the whole campaign less than 15 minutes after the final whistle was rushed and bizarre.
I'm sure that expert panel - Stuart Barnes (Sky Sports/The Sunday Times), Chris Jones (BBC Radio 5 Live), Matthieu Lartot (France Televisions), Emmanuel Massicard (Midi Olympique), Brian O’Driscoll (BT Sport), Dimitri Yachvili (beIN SPORTS) - all met beforehand to discuss the frontrunners but all of them were flat-out working at the stadium as the game finished.
Barnes, Jones, Lartot, Massicard, O'Driscoll and Yachvili surely did not get time in their heaped work schedules to meet up in the stands and argue over who was really the best player over the course of the competition. How could they?
In the final itself, a new contender had emerged. He had not come out of nowhere.
No, James Ryan had in fact played all nine of Leinster's games in Europe. Granted, he was a sub in four of the six pool pages but he did well, home and away, against Montpellier. He was a titan in the quarter final win over Saracens and near unstoppable in the semi-final annihilation of Scarlets.
And then in the final, Ryan was far and away the best player from either side. He delivered constant front-foot ball, he punched holes, he was superb in the lineout and he worked his rear off making tackles and clearing out rucks. Man of the match in the most important game of the year. Nakarawa had a decent outing but Leinster nullified his attacking threat and he was extremely lucky to avoid being sin-binned for a deliberate knock-on.
Nakarawa, Fardy, Ryan, Sexton, Furlong and even the injured but brilliant Machenaud.
All deserve to be in the conversation but why rush the conversation. Give it an hour for God's sake. Nobody's going to mind.Peter O’Mahony open to Munster role after huge criticism of province
Fascinating insights from POM. Peter O’Mahony became the latest ex-player to criticise the management of Munster rugby; first in extracts from his new autobiography, All In, and now from a revealing chat with the Irish Independent. Last year, former scrum-half Conor Murray made headlines when he lambasted the Munster hierarchy. When asked whether he felt […]
Rugby
4 days ago
Ex-England star in frame for Ireland squad after superb Munster debut
A quality signing it seems! The signing of Kieran Brookes was met with scepticism by some Munster supporters, earlier this year; and, indeed, the signing of a 36-year-old, who hadn’t played international rugby since 2016 – bar an appearance for the Barbarians – didn’t seem on par with the signing of hooker, and South Africa […]
Rugby
6 days ago
Rugby
Rugby