Search icon

GAA

04th Feb 2016

Concussion victim Kevin Downes says it was “blatantly obvious” Lee Keegan should have been substituted

Not open for debate

Kevin McGillicuddy

Lots of people have an opinion on concussion but they are not all equal.

Kevin Downes missed Na Piarsaigh’s AIB Munster club hurling final triumph over Ballygunner late last year after suffering a blow to the head in the semi-final win over Thurles Sarsfields.

So, with the debate over Lee Keegan’s delayed substitution in Cork on Sunday still raging, the Limerick forward was well placed to give his assessment.

He didn’t mince his words.

“Mayo came out and said he should have come off – and he should have. It was blatantly obvious he should have come off. Everyone is getting more aware of it now. It is a serious injury.”

Limerick County Senior Hurling Championship Final, Gaelic Grounds, Co. Limerick 6/10/2013 Na Piarsaigh vs Adare Kevin Downes in action for Na Piarsaigh Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/Ken Sutton

The AIB Munster club hurler of the year for 2015/16 was a frustrated figure after missing out on the club’s win over the Waterford champions, but as he explains, it was not any GAA protocol that saw him sit on the sideline. Instead, a medical decision taken by the club doctor was the key factor in his absence.
“To give credit to Dave Boylan, the club doctor, he’s straight down the middle with these things. I don’t think he would have put me on if I was in that state.
 
“Concussion is tough to define. Okay, I knew I was after getting a bang on the head – I was feeling blurred, dizzy. But it’s very hard to say, ‘Yes, you are clinically concussed’. If it’s blatantly obvious, there is a fair old chance you have it.”

Limerick Senior Hurling Championship Final, Gaelic Grounds, Limerick 11/10/2015 Na Piarsaigh vs Patrickswell Na Piarsaigh's Kevin Downes Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/Keith Wiseman

Downes missed a number of games in 2012 also after a severe knock to his head. The 2015/16 Munster club hurler of the year will thankfully be back for this weekend’s All-Ireland club semi-final clash with Oulart-The Ballagh, but admits that initial injury was frightening.
“If you were looking at the television, it’s very hard to focus your eyes. Blurred vision. You don’t feel well at all… dizzy. Getting pale. Fatigue sets in. You’re straining your eyes. Any movement effects you.
 
“Apart from the medical side of things, playing a game of hurling wouldn’t be ideal with the ball fizzing around.”
Downes was keen to clear up that it wasn’t rugby-style “protocols” that kept him out of the Ballygunner game, but rather the simple fact he wasn’t fit to play.

“People were saying to me that it was just protocol that wasn’t allowing me to play but the symptoms don’t allow you to play. Bar the obvious dangers that have been publicised recently, the symptoms alone will stop you.”

Downes holds a bizarre record in having never lost a game in the Munster club series, but also having failed to win a single game outside of his province.
His club have been caught cold by both Loughgiel Shamrocks and Portumna in recent years.  The forward is hopeful of avoiding a repeat this weekend against the Leinster and Wexford champions, but admits the loss to the Antrim side hurt the most back in 2011.

3 February 2016; Pictured is Kevin Downes from Na Piarsaigh who picked up the award for #TheToughest Munster Hurler at the AIB GAA Provincial Player Awards. AIB, sponsor to both the GAA and Camogie Club Championships, today honoured eleven club players from camogie, football and hurling. For exclusive content and to see why AIB are backing Club and County follow us @AIB_GAA and on Facebook at Facebook.com/AIBGAA. Croke Park, Dublin. Picture credit: Stephen McCarthy / SPORTSFILE *** NO REPRODUCTION FEE ***

“It was Loughgiel’s first time maybe getting national exposure. They’re a super team and maybe didn’t get the credit beforehand but once they took our scalp everyone was well aware of it. Unfortunately for us we were the guinea pigs for it maybe but definitely we were startled at the start.”

Brought to you by AIB GAA, proudly backing Club & County. Follow AIB GAA on TwitterInstagram and Facebook.

The FootballJOE quiz: Were you paying attention? – episode 10