Liam Sheedy saw a throw, Derek McGrath saw a hand-pass.
We're talking Patrick Curran's pass to Michael Kiely for Waterford's first goal in the Munster championship and if, with the aid of slowed-down and zoomed-in replays, a pair of grown men can't come to an agreement then what hope have referees without them? All they have is a pair of eyes and a game that, in front of them, is moving at 90 miles an hour.
For what it's worth, it did look like Curran threw the ball but that's not the conversation Conor O'Donovan is interested in having. The two-time All-Ireland winner doesn't want to know if it was or if it wasn't because at this stage, like many others, he's sick trying to find out.
It was back in 2019 when the two-time All-Ireland winner began his crusade against the hurling hand-pass as it's currently officiated and it was last year when he sent a letter to the GAA's director general Tom Ryan to try and change things. In that letter, the Tipperary man touched on the "ineffectiveness" of the current rule and the "blight" that throwing the ball has become.
So he proposed a solution. O'Donovan backed the introduction of a rule which deems it a foul
"to either hand-pass the ball, or palm the ball directly from the same hand that's holding the ball."
This would make for a change from the current rule, which calls for a "definite striking action" from the hand and today, O'Donovan explained to us the logic behind his idea.
"After that, it's up to players as to how they play the ball. They can hand-pass from the other hand, play it from the hurley, they can flick it off the hurley."
https://twitter.com/RTEgaa/status/1087785968222986240
The standing committee on playing rules decided against bringing O'Donovan's proposal to congress last year but he's hoping that, with controversies striking almost every weekend, and with throws to be seen in every match, it all might result in his proposal being considered and voted on next year.
"It's becoming nearly embarrassing watching hurling at the minute, what's going on," O'Donovan says.
"For me, I find it very hard to enjoy a game of hurling now, because the ball-throwing problem is a constant distraction. And that's how it is for a lot of people.
"I'm hoping that by getting it highlighted this year again that by the time congress comes around next year, that the GAA will have it as a motion to be voted on. Clearly, the rules at the minute are not working."
"I sent my letter to Tom Ryan and enclosed in it was a petition, signed by over 100 people, just to let him know that a lot of people out there are very dis-satisfied with the issue. You're talking about Eddie Keher, Noel Lane, Justin McCarthy, Joachim Kelly, who signed it in support of this solution."
Speaking on this week's GAA Hour, former Clare forward Darach Honan advocated for the same rule change.
"The hand-passing issue is a huge issue," said the 2013 All-Ireland winner, "because it's unreffable, it's unenforceable, the rule as is at the moment."
[caption id="attachment_258129" align="alignnone" width="1300"]
28 September 2013; Darach Honan, Clare, celebrates at the end of the game. GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Final Replay, Cork v Clare, Croke Park, Dublin. Picture credit: David Maher / SPORTSFILE[/caption]
"There have been a lot of examples of throws over the last few weeks and they could be throws as clear as day...but you still have lads saying it was a hand-pass," the Clonlara club-man added.
"I think you need a rule-change on that hand-pass. Having to switch hands when you're hand-passing the ball. That's the only way you could clearly see it. At the moment, you just couldn't ref it."
