Search icon

Football

25th Jul 2018

Eamon Dunphy wasn’t always right, but he was never boring

Robert Redmond

Eamon Dunphy has left RTE after 40 years with the broadcasters.

Dunphy announced his decision on Wednesday afternoon and said that he had informed RTE two years ago that he wouldn’t be signing a new contract. The 72-year-old said his main focus will now be on his podcast, The Stand.

“Two years ago, I decided not to renew my contract with RTÉ Sport,” he tweeted.

“At the time, they prevailed upon me to stay and, in fact, offered me a rise, a small one, to do so. However, before the World Cup I told them this time, I would be leaving. I intend to focus on my podcast The Stand which is flourishing and has had over 2.3 million listens since we started. That’s where my energy will now be devoted. In my 40 years with RTÉ, I made many good friends and I wish them the very best for the future.”

Dunphy was an apprentice with Manchester United and spent most of his playing career with Millwall. He made 23 appearances for the Republic of Ireland. Following his retirement from professional football, Dunphy became a journalist and an author. His was the ghostwriter for Roy Keane’s first autobiography, wrote a book on Irish band U2 and a biography of Matt Busby.

Along with John Giles, Liam Brady and the late Bill O’Herlihy, Dunphy was a staple of RTE’s football’s coverage for years. Former presenter O’Herlihy retired after the 2014 World Cup and sadly passed away a year later. Giles’ last appearance on RTE was the Euro 2016 final and Dunphy’s final broadcast for the station was the World Cup final. Brady is the only remaining member of the famous panel.

He wasn’t universally popular with viewers, but Dunphy’s departure marks the end of an era for Irish football broadcasting. There are fans in their 40s now who don’t remember football on RTE before Dunphy.

His departure provoked a strong reaction from football fans. Like with the pundit himself, opinion is divided. Some are glad to see the back of him, others will miss him.

https://twitter.com/vinfox/status/1022109558066561025

https://twitter.com/AodhBC/status/1022110947459121152

https://twitter.com/gerconnolly/status/1022116837981597697

Dunphy was never afraid to call it and was often too eager to make a big call. This was the case until his final appearances on RTE.

He completely bought into the England hype. He praised the country’s “tolerance” and National Health Service before the Sweden quarter-final and seemed incapable of separating the country from the team.

England provided Dunphy with a livelihood as a footballer in his youth and the country may have the NHS, but they also had Jordan Henderson in midfield.

Before England’s semi-final against Croatia at the World Cup, he predicted that England would win and go onto the final. He referenced their “character” and praised Gareth Southgate. Two hours later he said England got “what they deserved” after they were outplayed. He often let emotions and sentiment cloud his thinking and his opinions would flip-flop, but it made for entertaining television at times.

Dunphy’s been great value over the years in the studio. He was never afraid to voice an opinion or row back on one he made earlier, and that made for a refreshing break from the punditry offered across the water. The RTE panel were often more entertaining than the match itself. O’Herily would deliberately go to Dunphy first with a question, which would spark a reaction from Brady before Giles had his say and provided the voice of reason. No matter who succeeds them, RTE will never find that chemistry again.

It’s been easy to dismiss him, but Dunphy carved out a career in the extremely tough and precarious world of professional football and made a successful career change to journalism. His diary of a season at Millwall, Only a Game, is still one of the best books about football ever published.

The second volume of his autobiography is due to be called, “Wrong About Everything” and it wasn’t his job to be right all the time. He knew that and he certainly excelled at it. But Dunphy was never boring as a pundit and he’ll be missed, even if it probably is the right time to make a change.

The FootballJOE quiz: Were you paying attention? – episode 10

Topics:

Eamon Dunphy,RTE